In its 2025 Comprehensive Plan, Upper St. Clair Township states the housing problem plainly: "older residents looking to downsize or young buyers looking for less expensive or lower maintenance options are unable to find a home that meets their needs in Upper St. Clair." The same document describes Upper St. Clair as "approaching build out."
That sentence matters if you're weighing Upper St. Clair against other South Hills communities and want a townhouse, a patio home or something smaller than a four-bedroom colonial. The township has identified the gap. Proposals to fill it have been before the Planning Commission this fall, most recently on its October 15, 2026 agenda. Even the developer's own timeline for the largest proposal puts new townhouses years away, so a buyer deciding this winter is choosing among homes that already exist.
What the Township's Plan Calls For
The 2025 Upper St. Clair Comprehensive Plan reports that roughly 95% of the township is residential and that housing "consist[s] primarily of single-family homes." Its future land use section names housing types the township may add: patio-style homes aimed at its 55-and-older population, plus garden-style apartments, condominiums and townhomes.
The plan also lists the places where new building could happen. It names a long-time family farm, greenspace along the McLaughlin Run Road corridor, about 50 remaining acres in the Deerfield development, greenspace near St. Louise de Marillac Catholic Church, and property near State Route 19 and Boyce Road. Two of those areas, McLaughlin Run Road and Deerfield, are where the current proposals are.
The Largest Proposal, on Its Own Timeline
The Thomas Property plan, filed as PLC25-0003, is a townhouse community proposed at 1512 McLaughlin Run Road. At the Planning Commission's August 21, 2025 meeting, Steven Victor of Victor Wetzel Associates presented 109 townhouses in two phases. The plan had one entrance from McLaughlin Run Road and a clubhouse with pickleball courts and a pool. The minutes describe two-story and three-story models, each with a two-car garage and a driveway that fits two more cars.
A commissioner asked about pricing at that same meeting. According to the meeting minutes, Victor said prices had not been set, but that he "wouldn't be surprised if they were $400,000-$500,000 per unit." He put the project about two years away from starting construction. He also called two and a half years a "conservative guess" for building both phases.
Counting from that August 2025 meeting, those estimates pointed to a construction start around 2027 and both phases finished around 2030. The estimates assumed approvals would come first, and the review since then has taken longer:
- September 18, 2025: The Planning Commission tabled the plan while a related rezoning request was pending.
- May 21, 2026: By then the plan had grown to 115 townhouses, and the Planning Commission recommended denial.
- July 6, 2026: At a Board of Commissioners public hearing, the applicant presented a revised plan with 98 townhouses. The site was described as 33.2 acres in Upper St. Clair and 8.8 acres in Bridgeville. The Board voted 7-0 to send the plan back to the Planning Commission.
- August 20, 2026: At the developer's request, the Planning Commission tabled the plan 6-0 so the developer could respond to engineering and staff comments.
- October 15, 2026: The plan was listed as old business, still seeking tentative approval, on the Planning Commission agenda.
The public record covers what was discussed along the way. At the August 2025 meeting, commissioners asked about the steep hillside, street widths and emergency vehicle access, tree buffers, and traffic review. Large sites usually get these questions, and on a sloped piece of land each one takes engineering time to answer.
Two More Plans on the Same Agenda
The Thomas plan is one of three. Further down McLaughlin Run Road, the Dawson Property at 1400 McLaughlin Run Road has gone through its own versions. On November 20, 2025, the Planning Commission voted 4-1 to deny a rezoning request there, tied to a 39-townhouse plan on 14.7 acres. By May 2026, the Dawson application, PLC26-0002, was a six-lot subdivision. The six-lot version also drew a recommendation for denial in May. The Board then sent it back to the Planning Commission in July, along with the Thomas plan.
The third plan, Deerfield Manor Plan No. 11 (PLC26-0005), first appeared as new business on the September 17, 2026 Planning Commission agenda. It was listed again on October 15, seeking tentative approval as a planned residential development.
| Proposal | Location | What was proposed | Next date in the record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas Property, PLC25-0003 | 1512 McLaughlin Run Road | 109 townhouses in Aug. 2025, 115 by May 2026, revised to 98 in July 2026 | Old business on the Oct. 15, 2026 agenda |
| Dawson Property, PLC26-0002 | 1400 McLaughlin Run Road | 39 townhouses in Nov. 2025, a six-lot subdivision by May 2026 | Planning Commission, Dec. 17, 2026; Board hearing to begin by Feb. 20, 2027 |
| Deerfield Manor Plan No. 11, PLC26-0005 | Deerfield development | Planned residential development | Old business on the Oct. 15, 2026 agenda |
In their current versions, the Thomas plan is the only one of the three presented publicly as a large townhouse community. It is also the only one with any price figure attached, and that figure was an estimate.
A Decade of Proposals on One Stretch of Road
Upper St. Clair has seen a plan for this land approved before. As The Almanac reported in April 2021, an earlier proposal called Tuscany Pointe planned 144 apartments at 1500 McLaughlin Run Road. The Planning Commission recommended it in 2015, and the Board of Commissioners gave it final approval in November 2016. The Almanac reported that in 2021 the commissioners turned down the developer's request for a two-year extension of that approval. When the Thomas plan was presented in August 2025, the minutes noted that the land had gone back to its original zoning after the earlier approval expired.
This history matters to a buyer's calendar because an approval does not mean homes get built. McLaughlin Run Road has had a fully approved multifamily plan once, about ten years ago, and no building followed. Whatever happens with the current plans, approvals are still pending, and construction comes after them.
What This Means If You're Buying in Upper St. Clair This Winter
For a downsizer or a younger household set on Upper St. Clair, the practical choice is among existing homes. The township's plan includes a photo of existing townhomes, so attached homes are already part of the housing mix. The plan still describes the township as primarily single-family homes, so attached homes are a small share of what comes up for sale.
One route is a smaller single-family home, where the age of the house shapes upkeep more than its size does. We cover how Upper St. Clair's building eras affect renovation budgets in our guide to the township's three decades of house. Another is a home in a subdivision whose association handles some exterior upkeep. Whether a subdivision has an HOA, and what that HOA covers, varies street by street, as our Upper St. Clair HOA and swim club guide explains. A third is to widen the search to neighboring communities with a different mix of housing, such as Mt. Lebanon or Bethel Park.
Sellers in Upper St. Clair can read the same records differently. A seller whose home suits a downsizer, with one-floor living, a smaller yard or a newer roof, is selling into the gap the township's plan describes. Those buyers have no new local construction to choose instead in the near term. If you're already an owner planning a downsize, our Mt. Lebanon right-sizing guide covers the timing of selling and buying, which works much the same across the South Hills.
A Few Questions Buyers Ask
Is the $400,000 to $500,000 figure a price list? No. At the August 21, 2025 Planning Commission meeting, the applicant's representative said prices had not been set and offered that range as an estimate. It is useful as an indication of the market the developer had in mind, and no more than that.
Where can I follow these plans myself? The township posts Planning Commission agendas and minutes, plus Board of Commissioners meeting packets, on twpusc.org. The Dawson Property is next scheduled for the December 17, 2026 Planning Commission meeting. Agendas note that items can change, and the Community Development Department at 412.831.9000 can confirm the agenda on the day of a meeting.
Is new single-family construction any closer? The township's plan pictures Bedner Farms as the site of new and future single-family homes in Upper St. Clair. Lots and pricing there are a separate question from the townhouse plans covered above.
If you're thinking about trading an Upper St. Clair house for something smaller, or buying into the township before any new townhouses exist, it helps to know what your current home would bring in today's market. Wendy Weaver can walk you through it, starting with your instant home valuation.